The NLRB’s 10(j) Injunction Saga Just Got Messier

by | Nov 17, 2026 | Courts, Federal, Labor Relations Ink, Labor Relations Insight, Legal, News, NLRB, Starbucks, Trending

As of this month, the courts are still battling over the 10(j) injunction headache wrought by the Biden-era NLRB. Under former General Counsel Jennifer Abruzzo’s oversight, the Board abused this mechanism in 2022 by using alleged, unproven ULPs against Starbucks to request a nationwide injunction through its Buffalo, NY regional office. These ULP charges were tied to Starbucks Workers United’s organizing drive, and the Board was effectively pressuring Starbucks to roll over.

Separately, a 10(j) fight over a Memphis Starbucks store reached the Supreme Court. The resulting ruling, Starbucks v. McKinney, resolved a circuit split but somehow didn’t end the saga. Now, a subsequent circuit split is widening. Let’s look at where the highest U.S. court landed, followed by the latest appeals court interpretation and where other circuits sit.

Starbucks v. McKinney: A Supreme Court ruling without finality

The 10(j) injunction was meant as an “in case of emergency, break glass”-level tool and extraordinary remedy to prevent irreparable harm. The Abruzzo Board felt differently, and Starbucks challenged one of the resulting injunctions all the way to the Supreme Court.

In 2024, the high court resolved a circuit split in McKinney by rejecting the lenient “reasonable cause” standard for 10(j) injunctions in favor of Winter v. Natural Resources Defense Council’s four-factor test, which requires a higher threshold. Now, appeals courts are coming to different conclusions on what the Supreme Court’s ruling means in practice.

The Seventh Circuit picks a side

This month, the full Seventh Circuit denied a petition to rehear Hamada v. Laborforce, a Sept. 2026 ruling from a divided Seventh Circuit panel. That decision affirmed the denial of an injunction that the Board sought after an Illinois truck dealership withdrew recognition of the International Association of Machinists and Aerospace Workers (IAM) following a pair of employee petitions circulated to build support for ousting IAM.

The Seventh Circuit panel had found, without deciding whether the withdrawal was legal, that “generic claims about erosion of union support” aren’t enough to establish irreparable harm and that courts must also weigh workers’ “right to refrain” from unionizing.

With this ruling, the Seventh Circuit aligned with the Sixth Circuit and disagreed with the Second Circuit’s approach, both discussed below:

– The Sixth Circuit reversed a district court decision granting an injunction against a Michigan hospital, which had withdrawn recognition from a union. In doing so, the Sixth Circuit’s GOP majority found that McKinney requires the Board to show likely irreparable harm rather than rely on speculative arguments to obtain an injunction.

– The Second Circuit went the other way by reversing the denial of an injunction petition and ordering a parking management company to immediately recognize and bargain with its valet attendants’ union. The court’s Democratic majority cited McKinney but gave the Supreme Court’s opinion little consideration while weighing irreparable harm and likelihood of success on the merits of the underlying ULP case.

Also previously: An unpublished Ninth Circuit decision didn’t cite McKinney while affirming an injunction under Winter’s four-factor test.

More cleanup to come, courtesy of the circuits

Where does this dispute go now, since there’s a circuit split over how to interpret a Supreme Court ruling that was meant to resolve a circuit split? If you guessed that the interpretation of “irreparable harm” could one day make it back to the Supreme Court for clarification, well, it could happen after more bumps along the road.

There’s also a procedural angle to this that can make 10(j) injunctions even more frustrating. They only last until the Board decides the underlying case, so a Board ruling can make an injunction fight moot while it’s still in appeals. Employers still must operate under an injunction in the meantime, which is about as convenient as one can imagine.

McKinney still made it to the Supreme Court, yet the ruling left lower courts to interpret the meaning of “irreparable harm,” which isn’t going smoothly. The Seventh Circuit flat-out acknowledged the split in a footnote, but that doesn’t mean much unless a losing party in a case like Hamada asks the Supreme Court to resolve the split, and the court decides to hear the case.

INK Newsletter

The Left of Boom Show

Labor Relations Certification

PUBLICATIONS

Archives

Categories