Strike Planning Starts Long Before the Picket Line

by | Nov 18, 2026 | Bargaining/Negotiations, picket lines, status quo, strike planning, strike preparation, Strikes

Every collective bargaining negotiation comes with the need to conduct strike planning and preparation. Unions decide to strike, and the employer must decide how to respond. This requires careful planning and preparation.

Strike planning involves more than lining up replacement workers. Security, vendors, legal review, and communications require organization-wide coordination while bargaining continues.

The tactics below come from a Left of Boom Show episode, Strike Response Planning and Preparation, where experts from LRI Consulting Services (LRI) discuss what employers need in place before a strike. The episode is part of Managing During Status Quo, LRI’s series for employers heading into first-contract bargaining.

Start a year out

In one first-contract case discussed on the show, planning began the week the union was certified. The strike came about a year later, and replacement staff arrived in time to keep operations running. Agency contracts and security arrangements alone can take months to put in place.

Decide how you will run the place

Start with the worst-case scenario, and everyone walks. Then model a situation where some employees cross the picket line. Most plans combine agency replacements, managers and non-union staff covering work, production shifted to another site, or inventory built ahead of a potential stoppage. Identify who can make staffing and operating decisions as conditions change.

The law matters here. Employers may hire permanent replacements in an economic strike, but not in an unfair labor practice (ULP) strike. Economic strikers who have been permanently replaced retain reinstatement rights when positions become available. Temporary agency staffing may be more practical, sometimes alongside permanent recruiting. Have labor counsel review the approach before committing to it.

Replacement workers need appropriate licenses, orientation, and somewhere to stay. One employer lined up its replacements only to discover every hotel in town was booked for a local event that weekend. Check the calendar. A union may choose a strike date that puts maximum pressure on the operation, including peak season or a major local event.

Protect the operation

Include the possibility of sabotage and disruption in your plan. Employers have reported missing equipment, clogged toilets, and flooded entryways during strikes. Audit cameras, gates, access points, and consistent badging practices. Duplicate keys for critical vehicles and machinery and have maintenance check HVAC and mechanical systems as a potential stoppage approaches.

Include your IT and security teams. They should:

  • Confirm who can enter facilities and use essential systems,
  • How their staffing rosters will be maintained,
  • How access decisions will be implemented.

Review any strike-related restrictions with labor counsel rather than imposing them automatically.

Know which trucks will cross

Identify critical vendors and have legal review their contracts. Some drivers may be covered by agreements allowing them to decline crossing a picket line. Explore alternative drivers or delivery points and line up backup suppliers. The episode recommends stocking two weeks to 30 days of essential materials and topping off fuel tanks where feasible.

Put a lawyer in the room on day one

Counsel should review replacement staffing agreements, picket-line rules, and response procedures. Write an escalation chart that identifies who has authority to act and when to call for legal advice. The supervisor on site at 2 a.m. should not have to guess. Run a tabletop exercise to find out whether the plan works before anyone needs it. (We can help run a tabletop if need be).

Pay attention to allegations that an employer’s unfair labor practice caused or prolonged a strike. That can affect whether it is treated as an economic or ULP strike, and therefore what replacement and reinstatement rules apply. A union allegation alone does not settle the question. In healthcare, special notice requirements apply, including advance written notice under Section 8(g). Strike law is technical, so keep labor counsel involved throughout.

Tell your side first

Employees who intend to work need clear information about entry points and workplace safety. Managers need talking points, and call centers need scripts. Community leaders and elected officials should be able to hear the employer’s position directly, not only through public accounts of the dispute.

Keep the message consistent and accurate by explaining the employer’s bargaining position and telling customers and non-union employees what operational arrangements are in place. Avoid promising employees or the community more than the plan can deliver.

Strike Planning if you cannot operate

Some employers cannot replace a striking workforce, regardless of the preparation. For them, readiness means building cash reserves and sellable inventory, working through shutdown scenarios with finance and operations, and planning for restart conditions. Communications should explain the likely effects on operations and, where accurately established, on employees’ pay and benefits.

Strikes are difficult

A strike plan does not guarantee uninterrupted operations. It helps management identify what the organization can sustain, where vulnerabilities lie, and who will make decisions if bargaining breaks down. For some employers, that means keeping the business running. For others, it means managing a shutdown and preparing to restart. Both require intense preparation and planning.

Go deeper

Watch the full episode and the rest of the Managing During Status Quo series at lrionline.com/bargaining, or call LRI at 800-888-9115 to discuss a strike plan for your operation.

INK Newsletter

The Left of Boom Show

Labor Relations Certification

PUBLICATIONS

Archives

Categories